When it comes to musical instruments, the Handpan and RAV Vast have captured the hearts of many enthusiasts around the globe. These instruments are celebrated for their captivating sounds, unique designs, and the immersive playing experience they offer. 

However, choosing between them can be challenging due to their detailed craftsmanship and different sound qualities. In this article, we delve into their development, sound characteristics, techniques needed to play them, durability, and other essential factors that might influence your choice. Whether you are drawn to the artisanal creation of the Handpan or the modern craftsmanship of the RAV Vast, you'll find comprehensive insights to guide your musical journey.

Instrument Characteristics

The world of unique musical instruments is filled with fascinating creations like the RAV Vast and the handpan. Music enthusiasts celebrate both for their distinct sounds and meticulous craftsmanship, and they find the unique qualities and shared traits intriguing.

Development and Makers of Handpan and RAV Vast

Handpans have an intriguing history. They are heavily influenced by the Trinidadian steelpan and have been shaped by various cultural instruments, such as the Indian ghatam and the Indonesian gamelan. The Hang, created by PANArt in Switzerland, was a pivotal development in the evolution of the handpan. 

Today, artisans worldwide craft these instruments, incorporating diverse techniques and materials that result in a variety of sounds and designs. In the United States, companies like Pantheon Steel and Arcana Musical Instruments contribute to this landscape, often offering custom scales and materials so that each handpan is truly unique.

Conversely, the RAV Vast is a modern instrument created by Russian engineer Andrey Remyannikov. He designed it as an accessible alternative to the Hang. Manufactured by RAV Labs in Perm, Russia, the RAV Vast blends elements of handpans and tongue drums. Its creation involves about 80 individuals dedicated to precision-crafted design and sound consistency. The RAV Vast uses advanced techniques with specially designed and patented cut patterns to produce rich, warm tones, unlike the handmade processes typically seen in handpan construction.

Physical Structure and Unique Features

Both instruments are steel-made but differ in build. Handpans use nitrided steel in a two-shell design for resonance, while the thicker steel of RAV Vast supports various tunings and play styles, offering versatility.

Thriving communities support and inspire enthusiasts of both RAV Vast and handpans, providing distinct musical journeys. Handpans, with their cultural history and artisanal craftsmanship, offer a personalized exploration, while the RAV Vast showcases the precision and innovative elements of a contemporary instrument.

Sound Quality and Sustain

The sound qualities of handpans and RAV Vast instruments have certain distinctions that make each unique. Handpans are known for their sharpness and depth, with complex harmonics and rich overtones. This gives them a dynamic presence, capable of creating an immersive listening experience. The wide range of harmonics makes handpans ideal for those who value nuanced tones that can easily fill a space.

In contrast, RAV Vast instruments are renowned for their clear fundamental notes and enhanced resonance. Each note resembles a small choir, projecting multiple overtones that produce a balanced and harmonious sound. This feature gives the RAV Vast a unique voice, setting it apart from standard tongue drums and offering a different auditory texture.

The duration of sustain is another aspect where these instruments differ. Handpans generally have a shorter sustain compared to RAV Vast instruments. The extended sustain of RAV Vast is a result of its meticulous design, which includes metal ribs and finely tuned tongues. This allows notes to linger, making it well-suited for meditation and sound therapy sessions.

Both instruments serve well in meditative contexts, with each having its own impact. Handpans, with their engaging and intricate sounds, are favored for situations that require a dynamic auditory environment. Their complexity is perfect for creating spaces that stimulate contemplation. Meanwhile, the RAV Vast excels in slower, more reflective pieces. Its deep, resonant tones invite listeners into prolonged states of relaxed focus, making it an excellent choice for yoga and sound healing.

For those choosing between the two, personal preference and intended use are key. A Reddit user noted the RAV Vast's depth and sustain as more appealing for long-term use in introspective settings. However, they also mentioned the importance of selecting the right model, as some may find specific tuning options less satisfactory. This highlights the need to consider personal experiences and understand the unique characteristics of each instrument.

Emotional Soundscapes: A Melody's Journey

Music isn't only about playing notes; it's about the emotions that resonate from them. When it comes to the Handpan and RAV Vast, each instrument offers a unique auditory journey that pulls at different strings of our emotional spectrum.

Rich Harmonics Comparison between Handpan and RAV Vast

Handpans are often described as sonic sculptures. Their complex harmonics are like layers within a sound wave, providing a rich and expressive palette for musicians. Every strike on a handpan produces not just a note but a rounded mix of overtones that can weave intricate emotional tapestries. This complexity allows handpans to convey a range of feelings, depending on the scale and touch of the musician. They're versatile, inviting you to explore both meditative calm and energetic crescendos through their immediate and full soundscape.

In contrast, the RAV Vast is your serene companion, known for the bell-like chime that resonates with a soothing, extended sustain. Although the RAV Vast may not have the same harmonic complexity as its handpan cousin, its reverb and balance provide a different kind of voice—one that whispers tranquility and reflection. The prolonged tones make it perfect for creating a calming atmosphere, which is why it's a staple in meditation and sound therapy practices.

Emotional Impact of Different Scales

Both instruments can establish profound emotional settings, but the scales they utilize are particularly influential. Handpans, with their wide harmonic range, can elevate emotions from one performance to the next. Their harmonics can evoke energy or tranquillity, making them adaptable to various emotional landscapes.

The RAV Vast, on the other hand, showcases its strength in simplicity; its scales like the C Golden Gate or B Celtic Minor distinctly shape its emotional impact. These scales are capable of creating introspective sound baths that are ideal for yoga and relaxation. Each note’s extended sustain works to wash over the listener, nurturing a peaceful environment perfect for introspection and healing.

For further insights, discussions on the Reddit thread offer first-hand perspectives from musicians.

Playing Techniques and Difficulty

When it comes to playing techniques and the difficulty of mastering the handpan and RAV Vast, each instrument offers a unique set of challenges and rewards. The handpan, renowned for its harmonic richness, demands a nuanced touch and precise control. Players typically employ a variety of techniques such as tapping, sliding, and slapping to produce its resonant sound.

Techniques for Playing Handpan 

Tapping involves striking the tone fields with fingertips to control pitch and dynamics, while sliding creates fluid transitions between notes. For a sharper, rhythmic effect, players might use slapping, applying a percussive strike with the hand or palm. Mastering the handpan requires regular practice and attention to dynamics, as well as using the whole arm and shoulder for power and expressiveness.

Techniques for Playing RAV Vast with Fingers or Sticks 

The RAV Vast's versatility and accessibility make it suitable for beginners, supporting various playing techniques with fingers or sticks. This instrument's forgiving nature makes it difficult to knock out of tune, allowing musicians to explore different strokes and techniques without worrying too much about maintenance.

Learning Curve and Skill Requirements 

According to a discussion on Reddit, the RAV Vast is often recommended for beginners due to its fewer notes and forgiving nature, while the handpan's broader range and technical demands mean it can require more time and effort to master. 

While both instruments allow significant creative exploration, the RAV Vast, with its forgiving touch and versatility, is often seen as a stepping stone for those eventually wanting to delve into the more intricate world of the handpan. Whether your preference leans towards the expressive depth of the handpan or the RAV Vast's adaptable nature, both offer a rich playing experience with opportunities for artistic expression and growth.

Durability, Tuning, and Maintenance

Musical instruments vary widely in their durability and maintenance needs, which often influences the practicality of owning them. Handpans, for example, are beautifully crafted and deliver a unique sound experience, but they are known for being temperamental. Their tuning is particularly sensitive to changes in environmental conditions like temperature and humidity.

Subtle Handle Required:

Careful handling is required to maintain a handpan's integrity and sound quality. Handle with care and store away from extremes to prevent detuning.

Routine Care:

Regular cleaning and oiling are necessary to protect a handpan from rust and corrosion, especially in humid or salty environments. These routine steps contribute to maintaining their condition and sound quality over time.

Better Option for Low-Maintenance Lovers:

On the other hand, the RAV Vast stands out for its durability and less demanding maintenance needs. Engineered for superior tuning stability, it can withstand a variety of environmental conditions, making it a robust choice for outdoor events or travel.

Resilient Build:

Constructed from steel of varying thicknesses, either 1.5mm or 2mm, and featuring a hydrophobic coating, the RAV Vast offers enhanced resilience against moisture, requiring minimal upkeep for optimal performance. A simple regular cleaning with a microfiber cloth is sufficient to keep its protective coating intact.

Community Support:

Another advantage of choosing a RAV Vast is the comprehensive community support and after-sales services available to owners. This feature provides peace of mind, particularly for those uncertain about instrument maintenance. Reddit users have expressed appreciation for the durability and minimal maintenance this instrument requires, making it suitable for active household settings.

Conclusion:

In summary, for musicians seeking a low-maintenance instrument that can endure varying environmental conditions, the RAV Vast is an excellent choice. However, for those who enjoy the hands-on process of caring for a handpan, despite its sensitivities, the intimate connection formed with the instrument can be worth the extra effort.

Price, Models, and Accessories

For anyone looking to dive into the world of handpans, understanding the price range and available models is crucial. Handpans, renowned for their unique and rich sound, begin around the $1,000 mark for decent quality models. Beginners can look at options like those from Aura starting at $875, while mid-range handpans such as the Xenith7 by Colin Foulke, priced at $1,200, offer features including nitrided steel and tuned ports.

 As you move up in quality, prices can stretch from $1,500 to $3,000, especially for models made in the UK, US, Vietnam, and Europe, with some custom models exceeding this range. High-end manufacturers like Pantheon Steel are known for exceptional craftsmanship and often charge a premium for their reputation.

RAV Vast instruments offer a more budget-friendly alternative without sacrificing much on sound quality, priced generally between $800 and $900. With models like the RAV Vast Low E Pygmy, they provide a tempting option for those limited by budget but still looking for a quality instrument. RAV Vast boasts a selection of about 20 models, varying mostly in scale and color, which gives players plenty of variety to choose from.

Accessories are also a consideration when purchasing these musical instruments. For a RAV Vast drum, additional costs might include the Original bag priced at approximately €50 or $55, and further accessories like playing sticks or a rope braid to safeguard the brass edge. Handpan accessories, particularly protective bags, can vary from €70 to €200 based on the brand and quality, adding to the overall expense.

For musicians interested in customization, investing in a custom handpan might be worthwhile, despite the potential cost reaching as high as $3,000. The price is greatly influenced by the reputation and experience of the maker, with renowned craftsmen often charging more.

It's important to note that geographical variations can cause considerable differences in pricing based on where the instrument is produced. For instance, handpans manufactured in the US or Europe typically come with a higher price tag due to increased production and labor costs, in contrast to those made in places like Vietnam or Bali.

Overall, whether choosing a handpan or a RAV Vast drum, evaluating your budget alongside the instrument's cost, the possibility of customization, and accessory expenses will ensure a purchase that aligns with both your musical aspirations and financial situation.

To gain further insights and user experiences, checking out resources like the following Reddit thread is advisable: [Reddit Discussion on RAV Vast](https://www.reddit.com/r/handpan/comments/bbq2rf/rav_vast_d_minor_celtic_vs_b_minor_celtic/). 

Size, Weight, and Transport

When deciding between a handpan and a RAV Vast, one key factor to consider is how easy it is to carry them around.

Comparison of size and weight between Handpan and RAV Vast

Handpans are generally larger, with diameters between 18-23 inches, making them quite bulky. Because of this, they can be hard to transport. You might need extra seats on a bus or plenty of space in your car's trunk to carry them around. Handpans also require protective cases that can range from lighter, less protective soft cases to heavier, more protective hard cases. These cases add to the weight but are crucial to prevent damage as handpans are quite fragile.

In contrast, the RAV Vast is much more compact. With a diameter of 51 cm and height of 17 cm, they're easier to handle and carry. Weighing between 4.9 kg and 5.9 kg, they fit better in small cars or tight storage spaces, making transportation straightforward. This is especially a nice feature for musicians who travel a lot or like to play in outdoor settings.

Importance of using cases or bags for transport

Both instruments need proper cases or bags to ensure their safety during travel. Handpan cases vary in price based on the protection level they offer, typically costing between 70 and 200 euros. The original RAV Vast bag costs about 89 euros and is designed to provide a balance between safety and portability, made from Oxford 600 and 400 materials and can be worn as a backpack. Buying these cases prevents damage repair costs. For insights and user experiences, you can check this Reddit discussion.

Choosing Your Instrument: Handpan or RAV Vast?

In the end, choosing between a handpan and a RAV Vast depends largely on your individual musical goals and preferences. If you're drawn to the ethereal and improvisational aspects of music, the handpan might be your best choice. Its melodic tones can add richness to your compositions and allow for spontaneous creativity.

On the other hand, if you're looking for an instrument that's both durable and versatile, especially for varying performance settings, the RAV Vast could be the way to go. Its unique harmonic resonance is both captivating and practical for diverse musical environments.

Ultimately, if your budget allows, acquiring both instruments can significantly diversify your musical toolkit, offering a range of sounds and possibilities that can fulfill different creative roles in your work. It's not just about the individual sounds they produce, but how these sounds can integrate into your broader musical vision.

The most crucial step in deciding is to experience these instruments first-hand. Recordings can only convey so much. It's in playing and feeling these instruments for yourself that you'll find the path that aligns with your passions and artistic ambitions.